Email a colleague    

August 2014

The Grey Market in Prepaid: Tactics to Combat International Bypass Fraud via the SIM Box

The Grey Market in Prepaid: Tactics to Combat International Bypass via the SIM Box

Telecom fraudsters thrive on complex, multi-party schemes to steal money from operators and governments.

One of the most successful of these fraud practices is to bypass licensed carriers by terminating international calls onto mobile networks through unlicensed operators.

The technique is to send calls via the internet to SIM boxes (machines that house 8 to 32 illegal SIM cards) which redirect this illegal VoIP traffic onto mobile networks.

In fact, at the biggest wholesale conference in the world I saw one company openly selling these SIM boxes on the exhibit floor.  So this is an integral part of a SIM boxer’s strategy — to attract “pirate” operators among legally licensed carriers.

Recently, Ahmad Nadeem Syed, Head of Revenue Assurance and Fraud Management at Mobilink in Pakistan, discussed with me the gravity of the grey traffic fraud situation.  And he has provided to Black Swan readers an excellent overview of the threat scenario, current SIM box fraud management tactics, and some suggested international measures to bring this fraud under greater control.  Ahmad’s hope is to stir up interest in having bodies like the ITU and GSMA take more action

Dan Baker: Ahmad, thanks for taking the time to reach out and help the operator community.  Exactly what corner of the market is affected by the SIM box threat?

Ahmad Nadeem Syed: Happy to help, Dan.  This “grey market” of international call bypass is a major issue in many, many countries.  It’s particularly serious in countries where the incoming international traffic rate is high and controls are loose in terms of availability of SIMs and law enforcement help.

The SIM box fraudsters mainly use the pre-paid SIM, the ownership and address of which is hard to know whereas post-paid SIMs are easily traceable because of address verification at the time of connection.

The affected stakeholders are the mobile operators, the legal international carriers, and the government.

What are the mechanics behind SIM box fraud?

To begin, traffic aggregator carriers sit outside the target country where the interconnect rate is high, such as Pakistan, India, Bangladesh, Indonesia, and many others.

In some cases, these traffic aggregators are getting traffic directly from operators too, and their interest is simply to make a profit by terminating traffic at a much lower rate.  And they do that by handing over traffic to illegal terminators in the target country.

Two years back it was common to see traffic coming through satellites, and that may still be true in certain countries even today, but now the common approach is to use broadband links.  The SIM Boxes are widely available and sold prices ranging between $500 to $10,000.

The idea is take the traffic from abroad at cheap rates, pass the calls over the internet cloud, and bypass the international gateway exchange.  The VoIP phone call is directed to a SIM box which makes an on-net call within the country.

The diagram shows the typical scenario.  The fraudsters usually take advantage of cheap packages including bundle offers, which earns lower per minute revenue to the operators than the interconnect rate they can earn from the international carriers.

In Pakistan’s case, for example, the operators are losing about half a cent compared to one cent per minute on the interconnect rate.  The loss to licensed international carriers is about 5 cents and the government about 2 cents per minute.  The winners are the fraudsters, who need a very small investment to steal big money.

International SIM Box Fraud

Any indication of the size of this grey market worldwide?

Estimating the loss due to by-pass traffic is not easy.  It varies from country to country depending on: international termination rates, controls in place, and traffic volume.  The grey traffic estimates I tend to believe are in the range of 10 to 30% of the mobile markets in countries affected by this issue.

What’s the profile of the fraudster operators?

There are two major players involved in this activity: (1) the fraudsters inside the terminating country; and (2) the illegitimate international carriers from across the border.

The fraudster could be a SIM box operator, a local loop operator or a national carrier license holder.  The SIM box fraudster basically sets up everything -- the SIM boxes, the connectivity, the manpower, and fresh supplies of SIMs.

The Local Loop operators, bringing in illegal traffic, may use their switches in place of a SIM box.  This makes it look like a local call using their own numbering series to terminate the traffic onto mobile operators.  The national carriers may bring in illegal traffic, change the “A” number to fake Local Loop number for each call and terminate the same onto mobile operators on their national trunks instead of international trunks.

The criminals are definitely well-organized.  So what can operators do?

There’s no doubt that the fraudsters are a step ahead.  They are clever enough to scatter their boxes throughout a city and use smart equipment to: mask themselves via “B” party dispersion, spoof the IMEI of SIM box device, and accept no incoming call/SMS, in that way preventing operators from learning the balance available on the SIM.

A single operator cannot control this grey traffic issue on its own.  In my opinion and experience, we not only need better SIM box detection solutions, but also greater measures to stop the sale of SIMs to fake subscribers: we need to check multiple SIMs in the same name, prevent the sale of pre-activated SIMs, and verify credentials before SIM activation.

Operators need to work with regulators to devise such policies and controls.  In Pakistan’s case, for example, SIMs are activated only after credentials are verified through a national database the operators maintain.  The fraudsters, however, have learned to circumvent this control.  So in Pakistan we are installing a biometric system where the SIMs can only be obtained through a thumb impression.  It’s a step in the right direction: I only hope it proves fool proof.

How do the fraudsters respond to these control measures?

The fraudsters are smart, techie and -- being from the same market -- they know how to outfox the local operators.  To mask themselves, the fraudsters like to host their equipment in places where their calls can reach multiple cells sites and get widely dispersed.  Another trick is to send out artificial SMS messages or accept a few incoming calls.  They even use moving vehicles such as vans to make their broadband connections.

How are the SIM cards themselves obtained?  From your average shop or retailer?

Once again, it varies by nation.  In certain countries, obtaining prepaid SIMs is not easy because they require some form of personal documentation and the sale of pre-activated SIMs is prohibited.  In other countries, though, there are virtually no checks because the operators are too busy trying to beat their competitors.

In Pakistan, operators sell their SIMs through their own distribution channels -- service centers and franchisees.  The operators cannot sell the pre-activated SIMs, so the buyer has to call the operator’s help line (call center) through a special short code called “789”.  The call centers are integrated with the Pakistan National Database Authority.

Even still, the fraudsters find ways to get around these roadblocks.  They allegedly using personal information from electoral lists (widely available after the recent elections), and bank accounts IDs (in collusion with bankers).

As I said, a biometric system is now being deployed.  So the question becomes, what will the fraudsters do next?

What should international telecom organizations do to address the grey market problem?

So far, the issue has evolved into a kind of cat vs. rat contest between solution vendors and fraudsters.  Unfortunately, the rat is winning all the time because of the fast evolving techniques used by the fraudsters.

It is therefore high time for International Telecommunication Union (ITU) to come forward to design new protocols for communication between handsets and the MSC.

Dan, here I would like to share with your readers my personal experience, which proved very effective for a couple of months till the fraudsters beat me again using smart technology.  I started identifying the IMEIs of the devices through link analysis and blocked them at the switch.  It worked great until the fraudsters started spoofing the IMEI to make it look like a handset.  This forced me to quit the strategy for fear I would block legal calls.  So even effective strategies often have a short shelf-life.

But here’s an idea I think has great potential.  We know each handset has a unique identity code called IMEI.  The IMEI -- which includes information on the origin, model, and serial number of the device -- contains 15 decimal digits: 14 digits plus a check digit.

Now this check digit is not transmitted over the radio interface, nor is it stored in the EIR database at any point.  So imagine if we used that check digit to validate the IMEI before letting it go through the switch.  Well, in 8 out of 9 chances a spoofed IMEI would fail the test so you can block the call.

To implement a control like this, I think the ITU should step forward, form a working group, and coordinate with the GSMA to develop certain protocols so all 15 digits pass through the radio transmitter so the EIR can validate the IMEI.

This tool could prove effective: blocking 8 out 9 calls will cause the fraudsters some serious financial trouble and mentally frustrate them.

Thank you, Ahmad, for this highly interesting and authoritative analysis of the grey traffic problem.  I hope that your proposal and insights get the industry-wide attention they deserve.

NOTE: Ahmad Nadeem Syed welcomes contact for further discussion of this issue.  Reach him via email or LinkedIn.

Copyright 2014 Black Swan Telecom Journal



Ahmad Nadeem Syed is a senior executive with 32 years of experience comprising 23 years in telecommunications; providing operational leadership with a strong track record of performance in high paced multinational organizations.  At Mobilink he is the Director of Revenue Assurance, Fraud Management, Cost and Margin Assurance, driving the company’s strategy of maximizing revnues.   Contact Ahmad via

Black Swan Solution Guides & Papers

cSwans of a Feather

Related Articles

  • Tokopedia, Indonesia’s E-Commerce King, Partners with 11 Million Merchants; Adopts Multi-Cloud to Drive Innovation interview with Warren Aw & Ryan de Melo — Indonesia’s Tokopedia, founded in 2009, has grown to become one of world’s leading e-commerce players.  Read about its success, technology direction, and multi-cloud connectivity adoption.
  • Bridge Alliance: Knocking Down Regional & Mobile Connectivity Barriers so Connected Car Markets Get Rolling in Asia interview with Kwee Kchwee — The CEO of an Asian consortium of mobile operators explains how they  help simplify and harmonize their members‘ operations in support of multi-national corporations.  This integration is enabling two huge industries to come together in Asia: auto manufacturing and telco.
  • Epsilon’s Infiny NaaS Platform Brings Global Connection, Agility & Fast Provision for IoT, Clouds & Enterprises in Southeast Asia, China & Beyond interview with Warren Aw — Network as a Service, powered by Software Defined Networks, are a faster, more agile, and more partner-friendly way of making data global connections.  A leading NaaS provider explains the benefits for cloud apps, enterprise IT, and IoT.
  • PCCW Global: On Leveraging Global IoT Connectivity to Create Mission Critical Use Cases for Enterprises interview with Craig Price — A leading wholesale executive explains the business challenges of the current global IoT scene as it spans many spheres: technical, political, marketing, and enterprise customer value creation.
  • Senet’s Cloud & Shared Gateways Drive LoRaWAN IoT Adoption for Enterprise Businesses, Smart Cities & Telecoms interview with Bruce Chatterley — An IoT netowork pioneer explains how LoRaWAN tech fits in the larger IoT ecosystem.  He gives use case examples, describes deployment restraints/costs, and shows how partnering, gateway sharing, and flexible deployment options are stimulating growth.
  • ARM Data Center Software’s Cloud-Based Network Inventory Links Network, Operations, Billing, Sales & CRM to One Database interview with Joe McDermott & Frank McDermott — A firm offering a cloud-based network inventory system explains the virtues of: a single underlying database, flexible conversions, task-checking workflow, new software business models, views that identify stranded assets, and connecting to Microsoft’s cloud platform.
  • Pure Play NFV: Lessons Learned from Masergy’s Virtual Deployment for a Global Enterprise interview with Prayson Pate — NFV is just getting off the ground, but one cloud provider to enterprises making a stir in virtual technology waters is Masergy.  Here are lessons learned from Masergy’s recent global deployment using a NFV pure play software approach.
  • The Digital Enabler: A Charging, Self-Care & Marketing Platform at the Core of the Mobile Business interview with Jennifer Kyriakakis — The digital enabler is a central platform that ties together charging, self-care, and marketing.  The article explains why leading operators consider digital enablers pivotal to their digital strategies.
  • Delivering Service Assurance Excellence at a Reduced Operating Cost interview with Gregg Hara — The great diversity and complexity of today’s networks make service assurance a big challenge.  But advances in off-the-shelf software now permit the configuring and visualizing of services across multiple technologies on a modest operating budget.
  • Are Cloud-Based Call Centers the Next Hot Product for the SMB Market? interview with Doron Dovrat — Quality customer service can improve a company’s corporate identity and drive business growth.  But many SMBs are priced out of acquiring modern call center technology.  This article explains the benefits of affordable and flexible cloud-based call centers.
  • Flexing the OSS & Network to Support the Digital Ecosystem interview with Ken Dilbeck — The need for telecoms to support a broader digital ecosystem requires an enormous change to OSS infrastructures and the way networks are being managed.  This interview sheds light on these challenges.
  • Crossing the Rubicon: Is it Time for Tier Ones to Move to a Real-Time Analytics BSS? interview with Andy Tiller — Will tier one operators continue to maintain their quilt works of legacy and adjunct platforms — or will they radically transform their BSS architecture into a new  system designed to address the new telecom era?  An advocate for radical transformation discusses: real-time analytics, billing for enterprises, partnering mashups, and on-going transformation work at Telenor.
  • Paradigm Shift in OSS Software: Network Topology Views via Enterprise-Search interview with Benedict Enweani — Enterprise-search is a wildly successful technology on the web, yet its influence has not yet rippled to the IT main stream.  But now a large Middle Eastern operator has deployed a major service assurance application using enterprise-search.  The interview discusses this multi-dimensional topology solution and compares it to traditional network inventory.
  • The Multi-Vendor MPLS: Enabling Tier 2 and 3 Telecoms to Offer World-Class Networks to SMBs interview with Prabhu Ramachandran — MPLS is a networking technology that has caught fire in the last decade.  Yet the complexity of MPLS has relegated to being mostly a large carrier solution.  Now a developer of a multi-vendor MPLS solutions explains why the next wave of MPLS adoption will come from tier 2/3 carriers supporting SMB customers.
  • Enabling Telecoms & Utilities to Adapt to the Winds of Business Change interview with Kirill Rechter — Billing is in the midst of momentous change.  Its value is no longer just around delivering multi-play services or sophisticated rating.  In this article you’ll learn how a billing/CRM supplier has adapted to the times by offering deeper value around the larger business issues of its telecom and utility clients.
  • Driving Customer Care Results & Cost Savings from Big Data Facts interview with Brian Jurutka — Mobile broadband and today’s dizzying array of app and network technology present a big challenge to customer care.  In fact, care agents have a hard time staying one step ahead of customers who call to report problems.  But network analytics comes to the rescue with advanced mobile handset troubleshooting and an ability to put greater intelligence at the fingertips of highly trained reps.
  • Hadoop and M2M Meet Device and Network Management Systems interview with Eric Wegner — Telecom big-data in networks is more than customer experience managment: it’s also about M2M plus network and element management systems.  This interview discusses the explosion in machine-to-machine devices, the virtues and drawbacks of Hadoop, and the network impact of shrink-wrapped search.
  • The Data Center & Cloud Infrastructure Boom: Is Your Sales/Engineering Team Equipped to Win? by Dan Baker — The build-out of enterprise clouds and data centers is a golden opportunity for systems integrators, carriers, and cloud providers.  But the firms who win this business will have sales and engineering teams who can drive an effective and streamlined requirements-to-design-to-order process.  This white paper points to a solution — a collaborative solution designs system — and explains 8 key capabilities of an ideal platform.
  • Big Data: Is it Ready for Prime Time in Customer Experience Management? interview with Thomas Sutter — Customer experience management is one of the most challenging of OSS domains and some suppliers are touting “big data” solutions as the silver bullet for CEM upgrades and consolidation.  This interview challenges the readiness of big data soluions to tackle OSS issues and deliver the cost savings.  The article also provides advice on managing technology risks, software vendor partnering, and the strategies of different OSS suppliers.
  • Calculated Risk: The Race to Deliver the Next Generation of LTE Service Management interview with Edoardo Rizzi — LTE and the emerging heterogeneous networks are likely to shake up the service management and customer experience management worlds.  Learn about the many new network management challenges LTE presents, and how a small OSS software firm aims to beat the big established players to market with a bold new technology and strategy.
  • Decom Dilemma: Why Tearing Down Networks is Often Harder than Deploying Them interview with Dan Hays — For every new 4G LTE and IP-based infrastructure deployed, there typically a legacy network that’s been rendered obsolete and needs to be decommissioned.  This article takes you through the many complexities of network decom, such as facilities planning, site lease terminations, green-safe equipment disposal, and tax relief programs.
  • Migration Success or Migraine Headache: Why Upfront Planning is Key to Network Decom interview with Ron Angner — Shutting down old networks and migrating customers to new ones is among the most challenging activities a network operators does today.  This article provides advice on the many network issues surrounding migration and decommissioning.  Topics discussed include inventory reconciliation, LEC/CLEC coordination, and protection of customers in the midst of projects that require great program management skills.
  • Navigating the Telecom Solutions Wilderness: Advice from Some Veteran Mountaineers interview with Al Brisard — Telecom solutions vendors struggle mightily to position their solutions and figure out what to offer next in a market where there’s considerable product and service crossover.  In this article, a veteran order management specialist firm lays out its strategy for mixing deep-bench functional expertise with process consulting, analytics, and custom API development.
  • Will Telecoms Sink Under the Weight of their Bloated and Out-of-Control Product Stacks? interview with Simon Muderack — Telecoms pay daily for their lack of product integration as they constantly reinvent product wheels, lose customer intelligence, and waste time/money.  This article makes the case of an enterprise product catalog.  Drawing on central catalog cases at a few Tier 1 operators, the article explains the benefits: reducing billing and provisioning costs, promoting product reuse, and smoothing operations.
  • Virtual Operator Life: Enabling Multi-Level Resellers Through an Active Product Catalog interview with Rob Hill — The value of product distribution via virtual operators is immense.  They enable a carrier to sell to markets it cannot profitably serve directly.  Yet the need for greater reseller flexibility in the bundling and pricing of increasingly complex IP and cloud services is now a major channel barrier.  This article explains what’s behind an innovative product catalog solution that doubles as a service creation environment for resellers in multiple tiers.
  • Telecom Blocking & Tackling: Executing the Fundamentals of the Order-to-Bill Process interview with Ron Angner — Just as football teams need to be good at the basics of blocking and tackling, telecoms need to excel at their own fundamental skillset: the order-to-cash process.  In this article, a leading consulting firm explains its methodology for taking operators on the path towards order-to-cash excellence.  Issues discussed include: provisioning intervals; standardization and simplicity; the transition from legacy to improved process; and the major role that industry metrics play.
  • Wireline Act IV, Scene II: Packaging Network & SaaS Services Together to Serve SMBs by John Frame — As revenue from telephony services has steadily declined, fixed network operators have scrambled to support VoIP, enhanced IP services, and now cloud applications.  This shift has also brought challenges to the provisioning software vendors who support the operators.  In this interview, a leading supplier explains how it’s transforming from plain ol‘ OSS software provider to packager of on-net and SaaS solutions from an array of third party cloud providers.
  • Telecom Merger Juggling Act: How to Convert the Back Office and Keep Customers and Investors Happy at the Same Time interview with Curtis Mills — Billing and OSS conversions as the result of a merger are a risky activity as evidenced by famous cases at Fairpoint and Hawaiian Telcom.  This article offers advice on how to head off problems by monitoring key operations checkpoints, asking the right questions, and leading with a proven conversion methodology.
  • Is Order Management a Provisioning System or Your Best Salesperson? by John Konczal — Order management as a differentiator is a very new concept to many CSP people, but it’s become a very real sales booster in many industries.  Using electronics retailer BestBuy as an example, the article points to several innovations that can — and are — being applied by CSPs today.  The article concludes with 8 key questions an operator should ask to measure advanced order management progress.
  • NEC Takes the Telecom Cloud from PowerPoint to Live Customers interview with Shinya Kukita — In the cloud computing world, it’s a long road from technology success to telecom busness opportunity.  But this story about how NEC and Telefonica are partnering to offer cloud services to small and medium enterprises shows the experience of early cloud adoption.  Issues discussed in the article include: customer types, cloud application varieties, geographic region acceptance, and selling challenges.
  • Billing As Enabler for the Next Killer Business Model interview with Scott Swartz — Facebook, cloud services, and Google Ads are examples of innovative business models that demand unique or non-standard billing techniques.  The article shows how flexible, change-on-the-fly, and metadata-driven billing architectures are enabling CSPs to offer truly ground breaking services.
  • Real-Time Provisioning of SIM Cards: A Boon to GSM Operators interview with Simo Isomaki — Software-controlled SIM card configuration is revolutionizing the activation of GSM phones.  The article explains how dynamic SIM management decouples the selection of numbers/services and delivers new opportunities to market during the customer acquisition and intial provisoining phase.
  • A Cynic Converted: IN/Prepaid Platforms Are Now Pretty Cool interview with Grant Lenahan — Service delivery platforms born in the IN era are often painted as inflexible and expensive to maintain.  Learn how modern SDPs with protocol mediation, high availability, and flexible Service Creation Environments are delivering value for operators such as Brazil’s Oi.
  • Achieving Revenue Maximization in the Telecom Contact Center interview with Robert Lamb — Optimizing the contact center offers one of the greatest returns on investment for a CSP.  The director of AT&T’s contact center services business explains how telecoms can strike an “artful balance” between contact center investment and cost savings.  The discussion draws from AT&T’s consulting with world class customers like Ford, Dell, Discover Financial, DISH Network, and General Motors.
  • Mobile Broadband: The Customer Service Assurance Challenge interview with Michele Campriani — iPhone and Android traffic is surging but operators struggle with network congestion and dropping ARPUs.  The answer?  Direct  resources and service quality measures to ensure VIPs are indeed getting the quality they expect.  Using real-life examples that cut to the chase of technical complexities, this article explains the chief causes of service quality degradation and describes efficient ways to deal with the problem.
  • Telco-in-a-Box: Are Telecoms Back in the B/OSS Business? interview with Jim Dunlap — Most telecoms have long since folded their merchant B/OSS software/services businesses.  But now Cycle30, a subsidiary of Alaskan operator GCI, is offering a order-to-cash managed service for other operators and utilities.  The article discusses the company’s unique business model and contrasts it with billing service bureau and licensed software approaches.
  • Bricks, Mortar & Well-Trained Reps Make a Comeback in Customer Management interview with Scott Kohlman — Greater industry competition, service complexity, and employee turnover have raised the bar in the customer support.  Indeed, complex services are putting an emphasis on quality care interactions in the store, on the web, and through the call center.  In this article you’ll learn about innovations in CRM, multi-tabbed agent portals,  call center agent training, customer treatment philosophies, and the impact of  self-service.
  • 21st Century Order Management: The Cross-Channel Sales Conversation by John Konczal — Selling a mobile service is generally not a one-and-done transaction.  It often involves several interactions — across the web, call center, store, and even kiosks.  This article explains the power of a “cross-channel hub” which sits above all sales channels, interacts with them all, and allows a CSP to keep the sales conversation moving forward seamlessly.
  • Building a B/OSS Business Through Common Sense Customer Service by David West — Delivering customer service excellence doesn‘t require mastering some secret technique.  The premise of this article is that plain dealing with customers and employees is all that’s needed for a winning formula.  The argument is spelling out in a simple 4 step methodology along with some practical examples.